Brand and Marketing Performance, Research, Consulting, Communications for Financial Services and Technology


 
Redefining direct-marketing success for a $50B business bank: Comerica boasts over 16 in-person appointments with "C" level decision makers for every 100 mail packages sent.

Challenge
Comerica Bank needed a way to boost acquisition for its mid-market business. With a hard-to-reach target of "C" level decision makers, traditional response rates of around 3% were acceptable, but not stellar. Only a portion of these translated to appointments, with fewer still leading to new business relationships.

Approach
MCorp. worked with Comerica to redefine success, using "set appointments" as a key metric to track, as an indicator of projected business growth. In-depth secondary research helped to better define the market, the audience's attitudes and needs, and the drivers of change. This helped us to answer a fundamental question: why would an otherwise satisfied CEO or CFO move his or her banking relationship? Utilizing this knowledge, we developed an overarching strategy, a fresh creative approach, and performance metrics to track success. This drove a series of direct marketing campaigns integrated with outbound telemarketing and a system to ensure follow-up by Business Development Officers.

Results
Return on this annual campaign continues to drive business success, as a result of our system for performance measurement and creative driven by a better understanding of audience motivators. Along with a series of DMA Echo Awards (three at last count) this campaign has boasted a steadily growing response rate - 7.9% to 13.4% to 16.1%.


View portfolio » 1 2 3 4


Industry:
Commercial Banking

Client:
Comerica Bank

Services Provided to this Client:
Strategic Planning
Customer Communications
Direct Marketing
Performance Measurement



The first year MCorp. worked with Comerica, they more than doubled response rates, from around 3% to over 7%. This garnered the first Echo Finalist Award.
Adding a follow-up premium and honing creative based on key metrics in our performance dashboard boosted response to over 13%, and won a DMA Echo Leader Award.
Strong results led to adoption by other Bank divisions. Appointments set hit over 16%, with over $55 million in newly related commitments booked. A third, just-announced DMA Echo Award will be awarded to MCorp. for this campaign.
With a chess theme highlighting the expertise and strategic thinking that Comerica bankers bring to every business relationship, this campaign is currently performing at a whopping 28.1% response rate.